[转]BBC 邀请钢琴家票选的20世纪20位钢琴家

jetsetradio

BBC音乐杂志2010年8月号用22页的篇幅的制作了一个专题，邀请了当今100位活跃在舞台上的钢琴家选出他们心中的最伟大同行，前提是每个人有三票，而且这些钢琴家必须是要有录音传世的。然后杂志刊载了全部的投票结果，并对前20位进行撰文介绍，在每篇最后还附上一句钢琴家本人的话，以及一张所谓的必备唱片。兹将投票情况摘录于下：
Leif Ove Andsnes: Dinu Lipatti ,A B Michelangeli, Geza Anda
Katya Apekisheva: Grigory Sokolov, Glenn Gould, Emil Gilels
Vladimir Ashenazy: Sviatoslav Richter, Sergey Rachmaninov, A B Michelangeli
Andrea Bacchetti: Murray Perahia, Miezyslaw Horszowski, Andras Schiff
Paul Badura-Skoda: Edwin Fischer, Alfred Cortot, Jorge Luis Prats
Jean-Efflam Bavouzet: Sviatoslav Richter, Friedrich Gulda, Arthur Rubinstein
Mark Bebbington: Arthur Rubinstein, Claudio Arrau, Aldo Ciccolini
Boris Berezovsky: Sergey Rachmaninov, Glenn Gould, A B Michelangeli
Idil Biret: Sergey Rachmaninov, Wilhelm Kempff, Alfred Cortot
Jonathan Biss: Arthur Rubinstein, Artur Schnabel, Dinu Lipatti
Alfed Brendel: Alfred Cortot, Edwin Fischer, Whlhelm Kempff
Ronald Brautigam: Artur Schnabel, Rudolf Serkin, Arthur Rubinstein
Iain Burnside: Josef Hofmann, Ignaz Friedman, Vladimir Sofronitsky
Joop Celis: Dinu Lipatti, Sviatoslav Richter, Arcadi Volodos
Caroline Clemmnow: Vladimir Horowitz, Sergey Rachmaninov, Radu Lupu
Arnaldo Cohen: Ignaz Friedman, A B Michelangeli, Martha Argerich
Finghin Collins: Sviatoslav Richter, Clara Haskil, Solomon
Paul Crossley: Alfred Cortot, Sviatoslav Richter, Emil Gilels
Jeremy Denk: Ignaz Friedman, Edwin Fischer, Gyorgy sebok
Misha Dichter: Artur Schnabel, Vladimir Horowitz, Art Tatum
Simone Dinnerstein: Myra Hess, Alfred Cortot, Artur Schnabel
Barry Douglas: Emil Gilels, Sviatoslav Richter, Daniel Barenboim
Julius Drake: Dinu Lipatti, Menahem Pressler, Radu Lupu
Danny Driver: Sviatoslav Richter,Alfred Cortot, Krystian Zimerman
Hans Eijsackers: Arthur Rubinstein, Igor Roma, Murray Perahia
Christoph Eschenbach: Edwin Fischer, Vladimir Horowitz, Sviatoslav Richter
Margaret Fingerhut: Arthur Rubinstein, Aurray Perahia, Krystian Zimerman
Michael Finnissy: Artur Schnabel, Nicolas Hodges, Ian Pace
Ingrid Fliter: Emil Gilels, Arthur Rubinstein, Wilhelm Kempff
David Fray: Wilhelm Kempff, Edwin Fischer, Sviatoslav Richter
Nelson Freire: Vladimir Horowitz Sergey Rachmaninov, Guiomar Novaes
Kirill Gerstein: Ferruccio Busoni, Sergey Rachmaninov, Keith Jarrett
Boris Giltburg: Arthur Rubinstein, Sviatoslav Richter, Vladimir Horowitz
Anthony Goldston: Artur Schnabel, Ignaz Friedmann, Gyorgy Cziffra
Helene Grimaud: Sergey Rachmaninov, Vladimir Horowitz, Emil Gilels
Benjamin Grosvenor: Alfred Cortot, Dinu Lipatti, Vladimir Horowitz
Michael Haefliger: Edwin Fischer, Radu Lupu, Wilhelm Kempff
Marc-Andre Hamelin: Alfred Cortot, Ignaz Friedman, Krystian Zimerman
Rustem Hayroudinoff: Sergey Rachmaninov, Vladimir Horowitz, Ignaz Friedman
David Helfgott: Sergey Rachmaninov, Artur Rubinstein, Vladimir Horowitz
Angela Hewitt: Alfred Cortot, Clara Haskil, Alicia de Larrocha
Stephen Hough: Alfred Cortot, Ignaz Friedman, Sergey Rachmaninov
Peter Katin: Paul Lewis, Till Fellner, Clifford Curzon
Freddy Kempf: Wilhelm Kempff, Vladimir Horowitz, Konstantin Lifschitz
Stephen Kovacebich: Sergey Rachmaninov, Vladimir Horowitz, Rudolf Serkin
Katia Labeque: Krystian Zimerman, Vladimir Horowitz, Robert D Levin
Marielle Labeque: Krystian Zimerman, Radu Lupu, Robert D Levin
Piers Lane: Martha Argerich, Sergey Rachmaninov, Ignaz Friedman
Lang Lang: Glenn Gould, Arthur Rubinstein, Vladimir Horowitz
Alain Lefevre: Dinu Lipatti, A B Michelangeli, Radu Lupu
Joanna MacGregor: Edwin Fischer, Arthur Rubinstein, Dinu Lipatti
Leon McCawley: Sergey Rachmaninov Matha Argetich, Murray Perahia
Oleg Marshev: Sergey Rachmaninov, Alfred Cortot, Emil Gilels
Philip Mead: Myra Hess, Walter Gieseking, Arthur Rubinstein
Frederic Meinders: Sergey Rachmaninov, Vladimir Horowitz, Josef Hofmann
Alexander Melnikov: Sergey Rachmaninov, Vladimir Sofronitsky, Walter Gieseking
Hamish Milne: Annie Fischer, Arthur Rubinstein, Artur Schnabel
Gabriela Montero: Martha Argerich, Julius Katchen, Annie Fischer
Olli Mustonen: Emil Gilels, Vladimir Horowitz, Josef Lhevinne
Noriko Ogawa: Sviatoslav Richter, Solomon, Daniel Barenboim
Garrick Ohlsson: Arthur Rubinstein, Sergey Rachmaninov, A B Michelangeli
Lara Omeroglu: Martha Argerich, Mitsuko Uchida, Lang Lang
Steven Osboren: Keith Jarrett, Bill Evans, Alfred Brendel
David Owen Norris: Krystian Zimerman, Arthur Rubinstein, Sergey Rachmaninov
Ian Pace: Vladimir Horowitz, Gyorgy Cziffra, Walter Gieseking
Lucy Parham: Mitsuko Uchida, Richard Goode, Andras Schiff
Francesco Piemontesi: Alfred Cortot, Wilhelm Kempff, Alfred Brendel
Maria Joao Pires: Sviatoslav Richter, Samson Francois, Radu Lupu
Artur Pizarro: Guiomar Novaes, Walter Gieseking, Grigory Ginzburg
Mikhail Pletnev: Sergey Rachmaninov, A B Michelangeli, Vladimir Horowitz
Jonathan Plowright: Ignacy Jan Paderewski, Erroll Garner, Bill Evans
Menahem Pressler: Radu Lupu, Artur Schnabel, Arthur Rubinstein
Vassily Primakov: Vera Gornostaeva Jerome Lowenthal, Sviatoslav Richter
Anne Queffelec: Murray Perahia, Alfred Brendel, Catherine Collard
James Rhodes: Glenn Gould, Ivo Pogorelich, Grigory Sokolov
Clara Rodriguez: Claudio Arrau, Teresa Carreno, Phyllis Sellick
Pascal Roge: Glenn Gould, Julius Katchen, Samson Francois
Martin Roscoe: Artur Schnabel, Alfred Cortot, Sviatoslav Richter
Charles Rosen: Josef Hofmann, Moriz Rosenthal, Solomon
Sa Chen: Ivo Pogorelich, Grigory Sokolov, Martha Argerich
Lise de la Salle: Annie Fischer, Sviatoslav Richter, Dinu Lipatti
Felipe Scagliusi: Vladimir Sofronitsky, Nelson Freire, Arthur Rubinstein
Howard Shelley: Sergey Rachmaninov, Dinu Lipatti, Martha Argerich
Dominic Piers Smith: A B Michelangeli, Vlaimir Horowitz, Arthur Rubinstein
Kathryn Stott: Vladimir Ashkenazy, Krystian Zimerman, Vlado Perlemuter
Yevgeny Sudbin: Benno Moiseiwitsch, Josef Hofmann, Grigory Sokolov
Jean-Yves Thibaudet: Arthur Rubinstein, Vladimir Horowitz, Samson Francois
Cedric Tiberghien: Emil Gilels, Dinu Lipatti, Artur Schnabel
Sergio Tiempo: Vladimir Horowitz, Matha Argerich, Alfred Cortot
John Tilbury: Dinu Lipatti, Clifford Curzon, Thelonius Monk
Martino Tirimo: Arthur Rubinstein, Claudio Arrau Sviatoslav Richter
Simon Trpceski: Sergey Rachmaninov, Arthur Rubinstein, Sviatoslav Richter
Roger Vignoles: Dinu Lipatti, Arthur Rubinstein, Murray Perahia
Lars Voget: Emil Gilels, Claudio Arrau, Martha Argerich
Arcadi Volodos: Sergey Rachmaninov, Artur Schnabel, Alfred Cortot
Ashley Wass: Clifford Curzon, Artur Schnabel, Krystian Zimerman
Shai Wosner: Andras Schiff, Emanuel Ax, Daniel Barenboim
Wu Han: Martha Argerich, Vladimir Horowitz, Menahem Pressler
Yuja Wang: Vladimir Horowitz, Sergey Rachmaninov, Ivo Pogorelich
附录：前20位名单及得票数
20: Claudio Arrau(4)
19: Josef Hofmann(4)
18: Walter Gieseking(4)
17: Glenn Gould(5)
16: Murray Perahia(6)
15: Wilhem Kempff(7)
14: Edwin Fischer(7)
13: Radu Lupu(7)
12: Ignaz Friedman(8)
11: Kristian Zimerman(8)
10: Arturo Benedetti Michelangeli(8)
9: Martha Argerich(9)
8: Emil Gilels(9)
7: Artur Schnabel(12)
6inu Lipatti(12)
5: Alfred Cortot(15)
4: Sviatoslav Richter(17)
3:Vladimir Horowitz(22)
2: Arthur Rubinstein(22)
1: Sergey Rachmaninov(23)

robotqyh

Langlang 喜欢的倒是和我蛮像的

majie

这个名单挺有意思，比很多无聊的排名正经多了。
陈萨和王羽佳都喜欢Ivo Pogorelich，这个和我一致。

ramos

12: Ignaz Friedman(8)

只有不到10张碟，而且录音质量普遍不行，都能排到这个位置

算有些人识货。

ybyan

完全看不到 lazar berman 的名字，有点意外。

芝麻汤团

和阿什肯纳齐一样啊

晨曦之星

贝奏三巨头上榜了两个……情何以堪

meaning04

没有Pollini ，Ashenazy。。。
很奇怪Rachmaninov会是第一。。。是他们想表达自己弹拉赫的都弹得很好的意思吗？

ramos

引用第7楼meaning04于2011-09-24 13:35发表的 :
没有Pollini ，Ashenazy。。。
很奇怪Rachmaninov会是第一。。。是他们想表达自己弹拉赫的都弹得很好的意思吗？

很正常……拉赫的演奏有一种能让人窒息一般的巨大魅力……所有作品到他手上都变成了他自己的作品，他的演奏理念也是独一无二的。

基本上上一代的钢琴家个个都非常崇拜拉赫......

meaning04

引用第8楼ramos于2011-09-24 15:12发表的 :


很正常……拉赫的演奏有一种能让人窒息一般的巨大魅力……所有作品到他手上都变成了他自己的作品，他的演奏理念也是独一无二的。

基本上上一代的钢琴家个个都非常崇拜拉赫......

sor。。。看来我需要把他得录音再翻出来过一遍。。。以前只觉得协奏和主题变奏还不错。。。其他感觉怪怪的。。。另外我觉得brendel也应该进前20的。。。

beetv

没有Backhaus，没有Pollini，费解。。。