求无损：Kodaly Quartet - Haydn String Quartets Op.3

qieli_bigfan

求Haydn String Quartets Op.3

qieli_bigfan

NAXOS出的这套全集Haydn - Complete String Quartets里没有op.3，维基百科里海顿四重奏作品条目里也没有op.3，是现在已经证伪了么？其实不是海顿的作品？

xiulok

封面上不是写着：Attrib. to Romanus Hoffstetter.

详情：
This set of quartets is now commonly attributed to Romanus Hoffstetter, though this is not universally agreed on. According to the scholar Allan Badley, "The works were omitted from the Entwurf-Katalog, the running catalogue of his works he (Haydn) kept from 1765 until after the London visits, but found their way into the Haydn-Verzeichnis prepared in 1805 under the composer's direct supervision by his faithful factotum Joseph Elssler. Haydn also accepted the six works as genuine in the edition of his complete string quartets published by Ignaz Pleyel. Unfortunately, both strands of evidence are not beyond questioning." Badley goes on to say "The meagre bibliographical evidence has been painstakingly sifted and the works themselves subjected to every kind of analytical technique known to musicology. Haydn's authorship still remains doubtful but so too does that of Pater Romanus Hoffstetter the most commonly favoured alternative."

jcshp

magnet:?xt=urn:btih:5337F7F8C0FC71B24DC8FA2009BDCD4862F3BF44